Product comparison · sources checked 28 October 2026
SSTV Signal Desk vs Black Cat SSTV: a detailed iPhone and Mac comparison
A good SSTV app has to fit the whole receiving chain: radio, audio or SDR input, decoder, picture archive and the next contact. This comparison looks at how SSTV Signal Desk and Black Cat's separate mobile and desktop products approach those jobs.
Disclosure and method: SSTV.org.uk is published by the SSTV Signal Desk team. This is our own product comparison, not an independent review. We checked Apple's UK listings, Black Cat Systems' product page and mobile FAQ, and our own product documentation on 28 October 2026. Black Cat descriptions below are attributed to its published information; we have not performed a controlled head-to-head decoder benchmark or independently verified every competitor feature. A feature not described in the sources is marked not established by the sources checked, not assumed absent.
The comparison covers the public Signal Desk 2.0.3 listing. The 2.0.4 (13) release note is a coming-soon preview; its changes are identified separately below.
First, identify the three products
SSTV Signal Desk is our paid Apple app for iPhone, iPad and native Mac. It combines analog SSTV with Weather Fax and digital reception, station records and satellite tools. Black Cat SSTV Slow Scan TV is Black Cat's separate iPhone/iPad app. Black Cat SSTV desktop is a different program for macOS and Windows, distributed by its developer.
| As checked | Signal Desk | Black Cat iPhone/iPad | Black Cat desktop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform | iPhone, iPad and native Mac | iPhone and iPad; Apple also lists Apple silicon Mac eligibility but labels the iOS app “Not verified for macOS” | Separate macOS and Windows software |
| Version in source | App Store 2.0.3; 2.0.4 (13) coming soon | App Store 2.0, dated 10 January 2017 in the UK version history | Mac download 2.5.1, dated 24 February 2024; separate 3.0.0b1 universal Mac beta, dated 30 June 2026 |
| Published minimum | iOS/iPadOS 16.6 or macOS 13 | iOS/iPadOS 6.0 as listed; Mac eligibility requires macOS 11 and Apple M1 or later | The 2.5.1 Mac download is listed for macOS 10.13 or later; consult the beta download for its own requirements |
| Languages in listing | 12 listed languages | English listed | Not established by the product page checked |
Apple's eligibility information does not itself guarantee how an iPhone/iPad app behaves on a particular Mac. Black Cat also sells a dedicated Mac program with its own features and version history; neither should be treated as a renamed copy of the other. Check the current Signal Desk listing, Black Cat mobile listing and desktop page for your device before purchasing.
Receiving a picture: automation and operator control
For a clean transmission, the first task is to get audio at an appropriate level and identify the mode. Signal Desk's listing describes live microphone and supported-file reception, spectrum monitoring, automatic frequency and slant correction, and saving useful partial decodes. Its Simple and Advanced views give an operator different amounts of detail. Those features make it useful both for a first microphone decode and for investigating a recording at a station desk. Signal Desk listing.
Black Cat's mobile listing describes automatic start and mode selection, as well as manual controls when the signal is difficult. Its mobile FAQ goes further: an operator can manually start or stop reception and choose a mode; when changing the mode during a decode, the FAQ says previous audio is decoded again for that mode. The phase control moves the picture horizontally, while skew adjusts the slant caused by a timing mismatch. Auto-save and saved-picture review are also documented.
Black Cat describes its desktop app as designed with weak signals in mind. Its desktop page documents an adjustable VIS detection threshold, automatic skew and offset correction after reception, and automatic image saving. Adjusting a detection threshold involves a practical tradeoff: a sensitive setting can also make false starts more likely. The description is the developer's stated design focus, not a result from our own sensitivity measurement.
| Receiving task | Signal Desk 2.0.3 | Black Cat iPhone/iPad | Black Cat desktop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Start and identify | Listing describes supported live/file receive and mode detection | Automatic start and mode; manual start, stop and mode selection documented | Adjustable VIS detector documented |
| Alignment | Automatic frequency and slant correction described | Manual phase and skew controls described | Automatic skew and offset correction after reception described |
| Keep result | RX archive; useful partial-image saving described | Auto-save and review of received images described | Auto-save to a chosen directory and gallery described |
| Weak-signal performance | No controlled comparative result in this article | No controlled comparative result in this article | Developer emphasizes weak-signal performance; no independent comparative result here |
What this means at the radio: automatic correction can reduce routine work, while manual start, mode and alignment controls matter when a signal begins before you are ready or the identification is damaged. Neither a feature list nor an attractive screenshot establishes which app will recover more detail from the same noisy transmission.
Microphones, files and SDR connections
A phone beside a radio speaker is a quick way to begin with either mobile app. Room noise, speaker distortion and automatic gain can affect the result; Black Cat's FAQ also discusses feeding audio to the device more directly. Its App Store listing describes Bluetooth audio support. Choose an audio path that your phone, interface and radio actually support, and check levels before judging the decoder. Black Cat mobile connection notes.
Signal Desk also documents supported audio and I/Q file replay on iPhone, iPad and Mac, remote rtl_tcp, SoapyRemote and SDR++ server connections, and Mac Core Audio input. The native Mac source list includes supported direct USB RTL-SDR devices. These are distinct input routes, not interchangeable server protocols; the available tuning controls and usable bandwidth depend on the provider. See our input and platform reference for formats and constraints.
Black Cat's desktop page advises a virtual audio cable or driver for use with SDR programs. The developer also documents a separate SDRuno plugin workflow on Windows, including streaming audio and tuning in that setup. That Windows-specific example should not be read as a promise of the same integration on macOS. The public sources checked do not establish equivalent support for each of Signal Desk's named network protocols in either Black Cat SSTV product.
For replay, keep the original file and its sample rate. For I/Q, also keep the encoding, centre frequency and I/Q channel order. A stereo audio file is not automatically an I/Q recording. A file that lacks the bandwidth of the original transmission cannot regain that missing information in the decoder.
Analog SSTV, Weather Fax and digital pictures
The products overlap on analog SSTV, but exact receive and transmit mode sets need separate checking. Signal Desk lists Martin, Scottie, Robot, PD, Pasokon, monochrome, FAX and AVT families. Black Cat's mobile listing names Robot, Scottie, Martin, PD and other receive modes and explicitly says that some supported receive modes cannot be transmitted. Consult the Signal Desk and Black Cat mobile listings and the in-app mode choices for the specific mode you plan to use.
Signal Desk's 2.0 documentation also describes Weather Fax, SSDV and DRM A–E reception. They are different signal paths, not alternative names for an ordinary analog SSTV image. Weather Fax is a monochrome scan with line-rate and IOC settings; SSDV assembles image packets after a supported link profile is decoded; DRM uses a digital multiplex and requires the appropriate service and image data to be recovered. Our protocol guide and sample library describe the input requirements and provide reference waveforms.
In particular, DRM Mode E requires suitable 192 kHz complex I/Q input; a phone microphone or ordinary narrow voice-band recording is not a substitute. The sources checked for Black Cat's SSTV mobile and desktop products do not establish those same SSDV and DRM workflows. Black Cat does sell other radio software, including a separate Weather Fax product, so this comparison should not be read as a statement about every product from that developer. Black Cat Mac product catalogue.
Preparing and sending an image
All three product descriptions support sending or preparing SSTV images, but a prepared waveform still needs a suitable transmitter and audio connection to go on air. Signal Desk lists image-to-audio transmission, RX/TX archives, callsign overlays, FSK/CW station IDs, templates and automated transmit tools. Check the mode and radio interface before a session. Signal Desk transmit description.
Black Cat's mobile listing describes choosing a photo or using the camera, adding text such as a callsign, and transmitting an image; it warns that not every receive mode can be transmitted. Its desktop page describes image transmission and a basic image editor, and says physical or USB-adapted serial ports can trigger PTT when needed. That documented serial PTT capability is a practical reason to consider the desktop product for an existing wired station. The sources checked do not establish equivalent serial PTT operation for Signal Desk, so do not assume that particular integration.
Avoid treating an audio export as proof of an on-air contact: the radio, PTT arrangement, operating privileges and reception at the other end remain separate parts of the exchange.
After the picture: records, sync and satellite passes
Signal Desk puts the receiver beside a station profile, QSO log, RX/TX history and satellite workspace. Its listing describes satellite passes, reminders and Doppler-aware tuning through supported providers. A predicted pass tells you when a satellite may be visible from an observing location; it does not establish that an SSTV transmitter is active during that pass. Check the activity log and the original announcement for a scheduled event.
When signed in to iCloud, selected station records, preferences, QSOs, satellite favourites and reminder rules can synchronize through the user's private CloudKit database. Decoded-image sync can be turned off; raw WAV/IQ recordings, receiver endpoints and calibration values stay local unless the operator exports or shares them. This distinction matters when moving from an iPhone to a Mac: a synchronized picture or QSO is not automatically a copy of the original radio recording. Read the storage and privacy policy for details.
Black Cat's mobile FAQ describes saved images and file sharing; its desktop page describes a saved-image directory and gallery. The sources checked do not establish a comparable built-in QSO, satellite and private cross-device synchronization workflow for those two SSTV products. That is a source limitation, not proof of what a separate Black Cat app or a user's external logging software can do.
Coming soon: our 2.0.4 (13) preview describes linking received FSK callsigns to saved images, sharing details and QSO drafts, as well as original-preserving repair and re-decoding retained source audio. These are preview notes, not features to assume are already available in the public 2.0.3 listing. Read the complete availability note.
Price, trial and updates
On 28 October 2026, Apple's UK pages showed £2.99 for Signal Desk and £3.99 for Black Cat's iPhone/iPad app. These are storefront snapshots; Apple may display different prices in another region or later. Black Cat's desktop page separately showed US$24.99 and describes a fully featured trial. Its registration terms include updates and new versions released during the following year, with continued use thereafter. The desktop figure is a different product and currency, so it is not a like-for-like UK App Store price comparison. Signal Desk price · Black Cat mobile price · Black Cat desktop terms.
For a limited introduction to our receiver, SSTV Lite is a separate free listing with a version-specific receive allowance and an optional permanent unlock. It is not the paid Signal Desk listing used in the comparison above.
Which fits your station?
- Choose Signal Desk when the value is a station workflow across iPhone, iPad and Mac: analog pictures, documented Weather Fax and digital paths, SDR/file inputs, QSO records, satellite planning and selected private sync in one app.
- Consider Black Cat's iPhone/iPad app for its documented automatic and manual SSTV receive controls, phase/skew adjustment and mobile image transmission, especially if its published device requirements suit an older device. Check the current listing on that device.
- Consider Black Cat desktop for Mac when its adjustable VIS threshold, receive correction, gallery, serial PTT and trial suit a desktop analog SSTV setup. Mac and Windows versions are a separate purchase route from its iPhone/iPad app.
For a fair practical comparison, start with the same original recording, record the selected mode and settings, and compare both completed and partial pictures. If testing over the air, use the same receiver and audio path, repeat with several signals and keep the original recordings. This article does not supply those benchmark results.
Sources and scope
- Apple UK: SSTV Signal Desk — platform, version, price and listed features.
- Apple UK: SSTV Slow Scan TV — mobile platform, version, price, receive and transmit claims.
- Black Cat Systems: mobile SSTV FAQ — manual controls, alignment, saved pictures and audio connection.
- Black Cat Systems: desktop SSTV and SDRuno plugin instructions — desktop features, downloads, terms and Windows plugin workflow.
- Our input reference, protocol guide, privacy policy and release notebook — Signal Desk's documented scope and version status.
The competitor information is based on the pages available on the check date, not a fresh hands-on evaluation of each current build. Prices, versions, availability and operating-system compatibility can change; confirm them with the relevant store or developer.